X02's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Pirate Collab]

Adeqaute

Really can't say I liked it much. The animation was good overall, but almost all of the animators seemed to animate something generic (except for Goatman, TommyVF and Marcy VF to point out the best), slap a couple of eyepatches on it, and call it pirate themed (for example, the stickmen or the skateboarding). I expected something that had more depth to it, which this collaboration sorely lacked. Enjoyed the song though.

Bertn responds:

lalala.

[From Life to Death]

Great Job

Well done. Put together with quality, and actually has some meaning to it. The only thing that made me take off a point was the feeling that it made some REALLY big jumps in his life--but then again, this is only the product of two days work.

Overall though, great job.

ReklessCreati0n responds:

Thanks for the review, which part felt like it jumped pretty far? Hmm well thanks for the review and vote!

[Mods day out]

<insert witty title here>

Hai Peanutbutter!!!!

Good movie btw, can't wait for part 2

peanutbutterclawk responds:

HAI EX OH TOO!!!!

thanks man.

[Breadfruit Birthday Bash]

Awesome

That was great! I got a good laugh out of it. Happy Birthday Breadfruit.

BreadFruitLock responds:

<3

[High On Life]

You Made My Day

After viewing 6 blams, that definately makes my day, great job, make longer ones in the future. I do random FBF stuff similar to yours, so I generally like anything of that style. Five'd

Striker028 responds:

Thank god for all the turd that's submitted to NG....wait I can't beleive I just said that....

[Ab Lone warrior]

NIce Job

Good Animation. Original and well drawn Characters. Music that fit the animation well. Good job, and good luck in the future

claude-kolodzinski responds:

thanks very much, good luck to you too

[Service Announcement]

You State A Good Point

I really think you've made a good point here. I just browsed the the portal and saw 3 submissions that had reviews by members who have no entries on NG saying things like 'wow ur animation style really sux' and 'i could have made a better flash'. My entries have reviews like that on them. The problem is is that the majority of NG Members don't have flash, have never used flash, and never intend to use flash. They think that every animation is supposed to be as good as the things on the top 50 list, and they think it is crap if it isn't. And other people vote and review unfairly because of 'prejudice'. Some people will vote zero on any Clock Crew flash, stick flash, etc no matter how good it is, or how much time the animator puts into it.
But the worst, in my opinion, is when another animator makes a jagoff comment because they have an animation ranked better than the one they're reviewing. They of all people should know how hard it is to make a flash movie. I know I'm a bit hypocritical (i only have 2 review written, but i'm starting to write more) but i've read a lot of reviews. Thank you for stating this point
And now, I end my rant

stoners-lunchbox responds:

Thanks for the quite lengthy review.
I noticed that you raised a couple of points that i didn't pay attention to. Authors do get kind of cocky too, don't they...

Thanks for the feedback!